6th Grade: A Heavy Crown

This week we wrapped up our look at the pivotal English Civil War, which ended with the execution of Charles I, and his son fleeing to France for safety (had he not made it, he would have been executed). How the English arrived here involved many different causes, along with a combination of explosive ideologies.

Among them:

  • A reassertion of the divine right of kings from a ruler with very limited political acumen, combined with the rise of Puritanism, which interpreted 1 Samuel 8 very differently from centuries of previous Christians.
  • Ships passing in the night between Parliament and King, where both sides were right in their own way, but about very different things so that the other side looked like an enemy.
  • Both King and Parliament attempting to one-up the other in crucial areas of hot button cultural policy
  • Both sides saw them themselves as defenders of the people and defenders of tradition, albeit in different ways. Charles was right that Puritans attempted to signficantly alter the country’s religious landscape, and alienated people by closing taverns, canceling Christmas, and forbidding sports on Sundays. Parliament was correct that Charles’ avoidance of Parliament, while technically legal, broke signficantly from the trends of monarchs over the past 100 years.
  • An atmosphere where rumor and offhand comments had explosive power, and seemingly could not get corrected by “the facts.”

An example of this would be what happened to the Duke of Stratford. The Duke certainly supported the King, and served as Governor of Ireland. Parliament would not grant Charles the new taxes needed to raise an army and fight the Scots, who resisted Charles’ religious reforms. As Governor, he had an army that operated independantly of Parliament. He wrote a note to the king in which he pledged his support, and said that his troops were at Charles’ disposal to “deal with the enemies of your majesty,” should Charles request it. Of course, the “enemies” he referred to were the Scots. But many in Parliament got themselves to believe that by “enemies” he meant Parliament. Rumor swirled that the Duke would lead a Catholic-Irish army into London to reverse the Reformation, and many believed it.

They arrested the Duke for treason and put him on trial. They had no evidence–everything obviously pointed to the Duke’s innocence. When it became clear that he would be acquitted Parliament switched tactics and instead passed a bill of attainer, which essentially amounted to passing a law that stated that the Duke should be executed. The catch? Parliament needed the signature of the King to make the bill law. Charles refused his signature, but riots erupted thoughout London, with some of them threatening Charles’ family. The Duke wrote to Charles, and said that if he could continue his service to the crown through his death, he would do so. If his death could preserve CHarles’ throne and family, and establish peace, Charles should sign the bill.

Eventually Charles signed. He would regret this until the literal day of his death. He hoped at least that his death might help him and the country, but in fact everything backfired. Not only did an innocent man die, but people saw weakness in Charles and ramped up the rhetoric and the pressure against him. Tragically, the Duke’s death made civil war more, and not less, likely.

The war itself see-sawed back and forth, with Parliamentary forces usually more numerous or better led. Charles I had courage, and involved himself in some of the battles directly. But, just as he did politically, he either vacillated or lurched in key moments

For our final debate surrounding Charles I, I want the students to consider the role of law and process in politics. Both sides wanted a certain result from their policies and ideas, obviously. At times, Charles went to the limit of proper procedure and legality to achieve his ends. At a crucial moment, Charles crossed the line and attempted to arrest some members of Parliament while in session. The fact that this failed because said members had advance notice and fled made matters infinitely worse for Charles. But Parliament went much farther, executing Archbishop Laud and the Duke of Stratford.

Then after the war, Parliament took the ultimate step. Charles signed onto a peace treaty that dramatically limited his power, but the king secretly worked against the peace and tried to restart the war. When that failed, they put Charles on trial for treason.

Obviosuly, both sides thought they acted from the best intentions and the right principles:

  • Parliament believed that they could no longer trust Charles, and so, he could no longer remain alive. For, as long he lived, Charles would try and reclaim the power he had lost and restart the war.
  • Charles no doubt admitted that of course he had deceived Parliament about his intentions. But the Parliamentary army tried to alter the English constitution, and so were traitors. He acted rightly, then, in doing all he could to try and stop them.

I hope the students could see how both sides justified their actions.

The question of whether or not the king could be guilty of treason was an open one. Perhaps Parliament could put the king on trial for treason, as no one disputed their right to put the Duke of Stratford on trial. However, the Parliamentary army leadership came almost entirely from the House of Commons, with most in the House of Lords siding with the king. So, when the victors put Charles on trial they did so without the House of Lords, which would be akin to our Congress consisting only of the House of Representatives. It would not really be Congress, but just the House.

When brought to trial Charles rightly saw that the trial could not be truly legitimate because “Parliament” was not putting him on trial, only a portion of the Commons. Charles refused to enter a plea, and in this act, refused to recognize the legality of the process. When remonstrated by those in power with the quote, “Sir, you are before a court of law!” Charles famously responded, “I see I am before a power” [i.e., men with guns].

“Parliament” convicted Charles in abstentia, and sentenced him to death by beheading, which he suffered January 30 1648.

The House of Commons then assumed control of the country, but had a hard time holding a governing coalition together now that they had dispatched their common foe. In time this coalition collapsed, and Charles I son Charles II became king. But the pieces of the traditional English monarchy did not fit back exactly the same as before, and a precedent had been set, and the seed had been planted for a new vision of how government’s should function.

Many thanks,

Dave

6th Grade: Welcome to the Jungle

Greetings All,

This week we continued with seismic changes brought about by the Reformation, which started as a religious movement, and then quickly morphed into vehicle for altering the entire cultural and political landscape of Europe. For better or worse, a new world emerged in the wake of Luther, Calvin, and Zwingli.

At the end of last week we summed up the differences between the different thinkers and movements in the following manner:

  • The Magisterial Reformation (Luther, Calvin, etc.) saw the church as corrupt, but the state as a secure bulwark either against the church or as a platform upon which to build a new society. Luther, for example, sympathized with the peasants who rebelled in 1524 but urged them to be crushed without mercy. Calvin wanted the state to work with the church to change laws and to use the force of law to enforce church teachings.
  • The Radicat Reformation (Anabaptists mostly) saw the church as corrupt, but also the government and the “world” as a whole. Everything needed torn down and rebuilt from the ground floor. They saw earthly powers just as much a part of the problem as the Catholic church. Everyone, be they Catholics, Lutherans, or Calvinists, saw the Anabaptists as enemies and persecuted them. To be fair, when Anabaptists had a chance, they did engage in some persecution themselves.

But the Lutherans and Calvinists also disagreed amongst themselves and persecuted each other. They agreed on the nature of salvation, but disagreed on how to apply their doctrines in everyday life.

  • Lutherans focused on freedom in Christ from the Law. The best thing we can do as Christians is to simply trust in the love of God and stop thinking about yourself. If you sin, that happens, use it to help draw you closer to God. Focusing on your sins, where you have been good, and where you have been bad, is just another means to keep thinking aobut yourself instead of God.
  • Calvinists saw Lutherans as taking the grace of God for granted. Christ saved us not to whatever we liked but to obey God and follow his commandments. God takes how we live seriously, and we should to. Being mindful of ourselves and our behavior is how we show how we love God.

I asked students how they would seek to resolve these dilemmas and choose who was right, or at least, more right than the others. They did a wonderful job of suggesting solutions and then adjusting them when others commented. It is certainly fine to be unsure about question like this, as these are deep and difficult questions. We will tackle why everyone persecuted everyone else for their beliefs later on, but Europe descended into chaos. Nobody had clean hands.

This week we looked at the English Reformation, inaugerated by Henry VIII, and continued especially via his daughter Elizabeth I.

As always, to understand the English Reformation we have to know what preceded it. We we see a particular swing of the pendulum we best understand it by knowing about the swing to the other side. In the early 1300’s, England stood poised to become the dominant power in Europe. They had a popular and successful king, they were winning a war with France, and they had more overall political and cultural unity than most any other European power. But over the next 100 years, they experienced a period of convulsive events that upended most everything:

  • The onset of the Black Plague (which also impacted the rest of Europe)
  • The death of the heir to the throne
  • A complete reversal of fortune in their protracted war with France
  • The abdication and mysterious death of Richard II
  • The unexpected early death of Henry V, victor at Agincourt.
  • The War of the Roses (1455-85) between the aristocratic houses of Lancaster and York, which saw the untimely deaths of Henry VI as well as Richard III.

Henry VII was actually a relatively minor Lancastrian nobleman who came to power in part because he was the last man standing. England needed and craved stability, and when Henry married Elizabeth of York, people were satisfied. England could move forward.

Henry VII had two sons, Arthur and Henry. Arthur died as a young man, leaving his son Henry the only bridge between future stability and political chaos once again. Henry was never supposed to be Henry VIII, but . . . these things happen, and they change the course of history.

Wherever the Reformation took root, it did so for slightly different reasons and took different forms.  Some say that the English Reformation was driven more by personality and nationality than theology, and there may be truth to this.  In time, Anglicanism would develop a distinct theological voice, but in the beginning the marriages of the monarch determined much of the course of events.

When we think of Henry VIII we often think of a domineering and abusive man, perhaps too much in love with his own power.  This may capture much of the truth of who Henry was, but he did not necessarily begin that way.  He had great intelligence.  He spoke fluently in perhaps three different languages.  He was an accomplished musician and dancer. He wrote a legitimate and scholarly treatise on the sacraments and he had He had a love for crowds and spectacle, and England adored him in the early years of his reign. He seemed genuinely in love with his wife Queen Catherine, who bore him a daughter named Mary.

But the fact that he had no son, and his wife was getting on in years, gnawed at him. In addition, he found himself head over heels smitten with another woman named Anne Boleyn. Henry insissted that his marriage to Catherine had no validity, because Catherine had been briefly married to his elder brother. The Church disagreed and refused to grant a divorce or an annulment. So Henry broke from the Catholic faith (he had made arguments against Luther years earlier) and made himself the head of the Church of England. After that, he could divorce Catherine and marry Anne rather easily. 🙂 Of course not everyone went along with this, and some (such as the Catholic martyrs John Fisher and Thomas More) lost their lives for refusing to sign on to the new order.

Had Anne bore Henry a son, who can say what might have happened, but Elizabeth was her only surviving child. Henry eventually accused her of adultery and witchcraft and had her beheaded. Anne protested her innocence to no avail. His next wife, Jane, died in childbirth. He divorced his fourth wife Anne of Cleve, and also executed his fifth wife, Cehterine Howard. His sixth and final wife, Catherine Parr, managed to outlive Henry. By the look of her, she may have been made of sterner stuff than his previous wives, having mastered the ‘stern library’ look. 🙂 Many credit her with guiding Henry’s son Edward (from his brief marriage to Jane Seymour) in the Protestant faith and making sure he held the Protestant line after Henry’s death.

No English king, with the possible exception of Henry II, had weilded more power than Henry VIII. And yet, I think that his grasping was not driven by strength but weakness. Many of his portraits cannot help but reveal a suspicious, gnawing insecurity. Here is a portrait of him as a young man, perhaps in the very earliest days of his reign:

And him in middle age well into his time in power. The wary eyes are still there:

Six years after the death of Edward VI (who died at age 14) his oldest half-sister Mary became queen.  History knows her as “Bloody Mary,” because of her persecution of Protestants.  In many ways she deserved this epithet, but we must try and sympathize with her.  Henry unjustly divorced and banished her mother Catherine of Aragon.  She had little contact with Protestants, and plenty of time to nurse a grudge, to plan to right the wrongs of the past.  We might understand better if we we realize that she thought that Henry had “ruined the country,” and God placed her in authority to bring England back to the faith and right previous wrongs.

To this psychological motivation we should add that neither Henry or Mary’s mother lived very long. What if she felt that she had precious little time to accomplish her goals before her death? As the saying goes, “Beware of an old man (or woman) in a hurry.” In this image to the right we see the same gnawing insecurity her father could not hide. Like Henry she knew she needed a son if her attempt at reform would last, but as an older woman nearly past childbearing years, she had little hope of a suitor actually appearing. We can lament the tragic nature of her life without condoning her actions. When we see her portrait nearly at the end of her life and reign, we see the same wary countenance as her father.

unframed presentation

It would be left to the daughter whose birth must have dramatically disappointed Henry, the daughter of Anne Boley, Elizabeth, to attempt to consolidate the turbulence of the realm. We will look at her efforts next week.

Dave