Greetings all,
This week we discussed Nixon’s groundbreaking initation of diplomatic recognition of China in 1972. This action was controversial at the time, and has had ripple effects perhaps even beyond what Nixon intended. If we want to clearly discuss whether or not Nixon made the right call, we need to understand the nature of “supplements” more broadly.
For our purposes, I defined supplements as something that exists outside yourself apart from the “normal” that you utilize to achieve a certain objective.
Some examples of supplement use might be
- Your shoulder hurts so you take a couple of Tylenol to ease the pain.
- You can’t sleep so you use a sleeping pill
- You are tired but need energy for work so you drink a big cup of coffee
- You are depressed and have a hard time dealing with life so you take anti-anxiety medication
We focused on typical supplements for our purposes in class. Obviously, taking meth would really give you an extreme boost of energy and focus, but thankfully very few make that choice.
There are a very few who never will touch sugar, caffeine, etc. They are purists and seek to train their minds and bodies to deal with whatever comes their way. If they have dry skin, they will avoid lotion and expect their body to cope, and so forth. But almost everyone uses something in some form.
Of course, technology serves as a supplement as well. To save time, we put our laundry in the washing machine, or use a lawn mower to cut grass. A very, very few, eschew almost all technological supplements. An old Chinese anecdote illustrates the nature of the exchange when we use supplements:
As Tzu-Gung traveled through the region he saw an old man working in his vegetable garden. He had dug an irrigation ditch. The man would descend into his well, fetch a vessel of water in his hands and pour it out into the ditch. Then he would repeat the process as much as necessary. While his efforts were significant the results seemed meager in comparison. Tzu-Gung said, “There is a way whereby you can irrigate a hundred ditches in one day with little effort. Would you like to hear it?” [He then proceeded to explain the pulley-system with a larger bucket and grooves running out to the ditches].
Then anger rose up in the man’s face. “I have heard my teacher say that whoever uses a machine does all his work like a machine. He who does his work like a machine grows a heart like a machine, and he who carries the heart of a machine loses his simplicity. He who has lost his simplicity becomes unsure in the strivings of his soul–and so we lose all honest sense. It is not that I do not know of such things: I am ashamed to use them.
Certainly we can admire the purity of the ideal. Perhaps isolated hermits could live this way, and we can also declare that hopefully some will indeed live according to this ideal, to remind us of it.But the rest of us are going to use things to supplement our lives.
When we use supplements, we run the risk of creating a “monster.” For example, many may remember the opiod epidemic from about 10 years ago. Feeling pain is certainly not a good thing, but getting addicted to opiods is worse than the pain itself. Most don’t get into that much trouble, but there is a definite line between enjoying a cup of coffee and needing the coffee to function normally. One first went to the coffee to fix a particular problem on a particular day. Then, the trick becomes not allowing the supplement to become the master.
Nations can also use other nations as a kind of supplement as well. This is a dangerous game, but many often feel it necessary. For example, during WW II one could argue that the democracies of America and England used the dictatorship of the Soviet Union to do most of the heavy lifting in defeating Germany. After the Battle of Britain, England and the United States shipped millions of dollars in weapons and supplies to the Soviet Union. We both used the Soviet Union to do the heavy lifting against Germany. This saved us countless lives and shortened the war dramatically, but in so doing, the Soviet Union grew substantially in power. They certainly grew more powerful than England after the war, and in certain ways obtained power on par with the United States. We lost control of the monster we created, and all of eastern Europe, and some of central Europe suffered for this during the next four decades.
One can argue that Nazi Germany was worse than the Soviet Union, and that Hitler was worse than Stalin, but the case is not a slam-dunk. We then had to spend the next 45 years defeating the monster we helped enable. The Soviet Union, alone among WW II combatants, achieved all of their strategic and diplomatic objectives.
This brings us to Nixon’s diplomatic recognition of China, which began the long march to our current situation. The Soviet Union had many issues. Perhaps millions of political and religious dissidents lost their lives and freedom in the gulags of Siberia, among other atrocities. But Maoist China was likely a more “evil empire.” But they were not as technologically advanced, and so not a threat in any way to us. However, Nixon had the prescient insight that their rivalry with the Soviet Union could be exploited in ways helpful to our security. We believed that in time, by drawing China further and further into the world stage, that they could be conformed to western ways, and the Soviet Union would be globally isolated.
So, we helped nuture China towards this end over the next 25-30 years. Among other things, we used their cheap labor to make many of the goods we used much cheaper, and increasing our standard of living. They anchored their economy through their purchase of our treasury bonds. We entered into trade agreements whereby we would buy their cheap goods and they would purchase our expensive technology. Both sides benefitted, and their power grew. Eventually we gratned them permanent membership in our most favored nations for trade. By then, the strategy against the Soviet Union had worked, but . . . now we had a new rival, and a new enemy. China was already far more populous, and would become far wealthier and more technologically savvy than the Soviet Union had been. As to whether or not China will become an absolute enemy on par with the Soviets, we shall see.
How can we know if using supplements is the right thing to do, or if it will pay off in the long run? No one can foretell the future with any precision. But there is a principle we can adhere to, and that is one of control, or perhaps a better word would be “dominion.” If you need a caffeine boost to get through the day, no problem. If you need it a few days a week, no problem. We have proper dominion over caffeine if we can use it or not use it at any time. The problem comes when at some point, you have no real control over the supplement, and the supplement starts controlling you. If you find that you cannot regularly go without the coffee, you have created a monster*–albeit a small and not very dangerous one–that you can no longer control. The tail wags the dog.
England and the US began to lose control of the Soviet Union in 1943, and Churchill saw this at the Tehran conference between Roosevelt, Churchill, and Stalin. Alas that Roosevelt failed to notice.
As to China, we shall see. The current incarnation of China has its issues, but thankfully China is not Stalin’s Soviet Union. But no one would dispute that we long ago lost control over what we helped create.
Dave
*By using the term ‘monster’ I do not mean to imply that we should never use such things. Again, sometimes you face circumstances that call for a powerful, albeit dangerous–and temporary–ally. I use the term to signify that we can lose control of such things rather easily.
*